Pesahim 97 - Lost Cause
Rabbi Richard Hidary
Pesahim 97 Shmuel Sin-offering dies = Pesah as shelamim [after slaughter] Sin-offering grazes = Pesah grazes [before slaughter] R. Yohanan Sin-offering dies = Pesah as shelamim BUT only after slaughter Q. sin-offering past one year grazes /= Pesah past one year shelamim A. Shmuel – only lost cases Q. if sin-offering found before replacement sacrifice then grazes (sages) /= Pesah afternoon b/4 slaughter shelamim Version 1 A. Sin-offering found anytime dies (Rabbi) = Pesah shelamim Q. Sin-offering found anytime dies (Rabbi) /= Pesah found before noon grazes A. before noon not called lost Q. No Sin-offering grazes… A. indeed, erase grazing rule Version 2 A. Slaughter is the cutoff Q. To contrast R. Yohanan, Shmuel must say noon is cutoff A. Sin-offering found anytime dies (Rabbi) = Pesah shelamim Q. Sin-offering found anytime dies (Rabbi) /= Pesah found before noon grazes A. before noon not called lost