Beisah 2 - The Chicken and Egg Problem
Rabbi Richard Hidary
Beisah 2 – Reason for Beth Hillel Prohibiting New Egg 1. Rav Nahman – Mukseh, Chicken for Laying Eggs Beth Shammai = R. Shimon = no mukzeh/nolad Beth Hillel – R. Yehudah = mukzeh/nolad apply Mishnah Shabbat 21:3 re bones acc. to Rav Nahman Beth Shammai = R. Yehudah Beth Hillel = R. Shimon Mishnah Shabbat 24:4 re animal food = R. Shimon Mishnah Beisah 4:3 re beams = R. Yehudah Chicken for Eating 2. Rabbah – Preparing from Shabbat to Yom Yov 3. Rav Yosef - Decree for fallen friuts 4. Rabbi Yishak - Decree for seeping liquids Sponsored by Gaby Khezri in Memory of Joseph ben Rahel