Sukkah 14 - Max Plank
Rabbi Richard Hidary
R. Aba – winepress vines are not part of grape R. Menashiah – hay for sekhakh hay is not part of grain [R. Aba disagrees] Baraita: using hay with grain for sekhakh Tanna Kamma – hay needs to be more than grain Aherim – hay needs to be more than grain + handles All agree not part of grain. Case of Baraita is when first intended for food. Mishnah A. Boards Rav 4 controversy: R. Yehudah kosher, R. Meir don’t sleep under it Shmuel 3-3.9 controversy: R. Yehudah kosher, R. Meir pasul 4 don’t sleep under it 1. Challenge to Rav 1 2. Challenge to Rav 2 3. Support for Rav 4. Support for Shmuel B. Sideways board Sponsored by Muriel and Alexander Seligson