Pesahim 60 – It’s the Thought that Counts
Rabbi Richard Hidary
Mishnah 4 activities For Pesah and for peace-offering For peace-offering and for Pesah Rav Papa asks – Within one activity, Pesah – Peace offering? Attempted Proofs that within one activity Proof 1 – Mishnah p. 1 Proof 2 – Mishnah p. 2 Proof 3 – Next Mishnah p. 1 Proof 4 – Next Mishnah p. 2 Does Mixed intention not on 14 Nisan validate a sacrifice? Rav Dimi – invalid – mirror image Rav Yirmiah – valid – unique and so weaker Rava – valid – default with intention, same if expressed Rav Ada – invalid – comparison to next Mishnah p. 2