Pesahim 59 - The Verse Leaves Us No Choice But to Reinterpret It
Rabbi Richard Hidary
Pesahim 59 - Order of the Evening: Baraita 1 Tamid (ben haarbaim) Pesah (ben haarbaim + erev) Ketoret (with Menorah) Menorah (from evening until morning) Baraita 2 Tamid Ketoret Menorah (from evening until morning) Pesah (ben haarbaim + erev) Baraita 3 Morning - First Ketoret (morning morning) Afternoon – Tamid, Ketoret, Menorah, Pesah And also atonement sacrifices on erev pesah R. Yishmael - all year round Why does atonement override tamid last? Rav Hisda – birds that aren’t burned Rav Papa – animal left on side of altar Challenge to Rav Hisda 2 Challenges to Rav Papa Rav Kahana’s contradictory verses Rav Safra’s contradictory verses