Pesahim 12 - Times They Are a-Changin'
Rabbi Richard Hidary
https://youtu.be/zWzt88yePfg Pesahim 12 – Margin of Error in Telling Time Mishnah Pesahim Rabbi Meir – 5 eat, 6 burn Rabbi Yehudah – 4 eat, 5 use, 6 burn Raban Gamaliel – 4 eat, 5 eat terumah, 6 burn Mishnah Sanhedrin 5:3 - Testimony Rabbi Meir – 1 hour difference ok (2 and 3) Rabbi Yehudah – 2 hour difference ok (3 and 5 but not 5 and 7) Rabbi Meir Rabbi Yehudah Abaye 1 0 30 minutes Abaye 2 2 minutes 1:02 Rava 1:59 2:59 How can they be invalidated as zomemin? Back to Hames Abaye – Why need to add so much time? Witnesses are more vigilant Rava – Need to add more time for error? Noon is distinguishable Witnesses are more vigilant [Extra time to gather firewood] 5 prohibited for a cloudy day 4 permitted because breakfast time More about eating times Rav Ashi – confirming the above