Pesahim 84 - Eight Bones to Pick
Rabbi Richard Hidary
Pesahim 84 - Mishnah – soft parts of baby goat Rabbah – cartilage is a lenient opinion Rava – cartilage is a prohibited example Sinews R. Yohanan – edible – current condition Resh Lakish – not edible – future condition R. Yohanan changed his mind Mishnah 2 sources that notar receives no lashes “Do not break a bone” Tanna Kamma - Only if valid Rabbi – only if edible What’s the practical difference? 1) R. Yirmiah – community is impure 2) Rav Yosef – valid and then invalid 3) Abaye – 14 Nisan 4) Rav Papa – limb half outside of Jerusalem 5) Rav Sheshet – partly roasted 6) Ranbi – fat tail bone 7) Rav Ashi – less than kezayit on limb 8) Ravina – less than a kezayit at breaking point